100YearsOfTV

Countdown #62

September 9, 1956

Shake, Rattle, and Ratings

[milestone_featured]

_______________________

September 7, 2027, will mark 100 years from the day when electronic television was invented.  To generate interest in the Centennial,  this website and accompanying podcast are going to Count Down the Top 100 Milestones from the First 100 Years of Television over 100 weeks until September 7, 2027.
________________________

________________________

Ed Sullivan was not the kind of personality you’d expect to find at the summit of the country’s cultural mountaintop, but by 1956, he was the weekly host of the top rated variety show on television. 

Edward Vincent Sullivan was born September 28, 1901, in New York City. His father Peter Sullivan was a customs inspector of Irish descent, like his mother, Elizabeth.  The Sullivans lived in a working-class, mostly Irish neighborhood in Harlem where the intensely urban, Irish-American experience shaped his pragmaticIc, stoic persona. 

As a teenager, Sullivan took up boxing, training and sparring at neighborhood gyms though he never fought professionally.  He was mostly looking for recreation – and access to the tightly knit world of sports in New York. 

Ed Sullivan, ca. 1934

By the time he finished high school in 1920, the connections he’d made led him into journalism, starting with short pieces he wrote for  the New York Evening Graphic and The Morning Telegraph, two papers well known for their sports and entertainment coverage. By his early twenties, Ed Sullivan was a full-time sportswriter and columnist – first covering boxing and baseball, then taking on theater and show business gossip.

When the Evening Graphic folded in 1932, he started writing a column called Little Old New York for the Daily News, which placed the column prominently and syndicated it nationally.   By 1936, Little Old New York was appearing in dozens of papers across the U.S. and Sullivan became one of the country’s leading entertainment columnists. His mix of Broadway reviews, celebrity gossip, and nightclub chatter put Ed Sullivan in the same league as more familiar Broadway columnists like Walter Winchell.

From Print To Radio to TV

After a long run in print, Sullivan shifted to broadcasting in the late 1930s, hosting programs that carried his mix of Broadway chatter and celebrity interviews to a national radio audience. 

During World War II he organized USO shows for American troops and contributed morale-boosting columns to military publications like Stars and Stripes.

After the war, Sullivan’s reputation as a talent broker and show-business insider brought him to the attention of CBS, which was developing a Sunday-night variety show for television.

Sullivan was hardly blessed with the kind of charisma or comic timing that came naturally to contemporaries like Milton Berle or Sid Caesar. He spoke stiffly, smiled rarely, and gestured awkwardly. 

But his gift was not performance, it was curation.  

The audience he’d attracted – and the industry network he’d built – was enough for CBS to anoint him as the ringmaster of Toast of the Town when it premiered on Sunday, June 20, 1948.

________________________


Full episodes of The Toast of The Town can be found on YouTube. If you don’t have time to watch the whole show, at least take a few minutes to see the opening dance number before Ed Sullivan is introduced.

________________________

Through the early 1950s, Sullivan’s flair for booking headline acts – from opera singers and comedians  to baseball stars and boxing champions – made Toast of the Town one of the most-watched programs on CBS. Its ratings consistently placed it among the network’s top ten shows, often ranking alongside or ahead of Berle’s Texaco Star Theater and Caesar’s Your Show of Shows. That steady performance convinced CBS to drop the generic title in September 1955 and rename its Sunday night tentpole The Ed Sullivan Show.

Black and White in Black & White 

What set Ed Sullivan apart from his competition was his instinct for what the public wanted to see, often before the public knew it wanted to see it. And one of his most radical instincts was his insistence on featuring Black artists on national television.

The very first episode of Toast Of The Town featured the Black vaudeville dance team of Dewey “Pigmeat” Markham and Johnny Lee. At a time when many sponsors balked at integration on television, Sullivan stood firm. When a CBS affiliate in the South threatened to cut away during an appearance by Lena Horne, Sullivan famously told them they could “go dark for all I care.” 

Ed Sullivan’s quiet determination to present Black artists as equals, garnered both admiration and death threats. 

________________________


It’s not “Pigmeat Markham, but here’s Cab Calloway on Toast of The Town in 1951

________________________

But to Sullivan, entertainment was America’s common language; if a performer could move an audience, they belonged on his stage. When CBS censors suggested he might refrain from “social gestures” like air-kisses and hand-shakes, Sullivan brushed them off, saying “The most important thing that we put on our show is everything but bigotry.”  

Which brings us to the most ironic of the roughly 10,000 performers that Ed Sullivan presented in nearly 1,100 shows over nearly a quarter century. 

The Largest Audience 

On September 9, 1956, an estimated 60 million viewers – the largest television audience ever to date –  tuned in not for one of Sullivan’s barrier-breaking Black artists, but for a white Southerner who some accused of stealing Black artist sound and style: Elvis Presley. ⁠1 

Contrary to popular memory, that September 1956 appearance on The Ed Sullivan Show was not the first time Elvis Presley appeared on television.  He’d appeared on several regional shows before appearing in January, 1956 on CBS’s Stage Show, hosted by big-band veterans Tommy and Jimmy Dorsey.  Those appearances introduced Elvis as a polite, energetic Southern boy with a curious blend of country twang and rhythm-and-blues swagger.

Six months later, on June 5, 1956, Elvis appeared on NBCs Milton Berle Show.  This time he was dressed in a loud checked jacket and performed his recent hit Hound Dog in a slower, more suggestive version than the record – punctuated by the hip gyrations that scandalized the nation. Critics called his performance vulgar; one newspaper called him “a juvenile delinquent.”

________________________


Yeah, this really happened

________________________

The controversy deepened a month later when Elvis appeared on The Steve Allen Show. Ever the urbane satirist, Allen tried to neutralize the uproar by having Elvis perform Hound Dog to an actual basset hound wearing a top hat. The bit drew laughs, but it also made Elvis look ridiculous. 

Ed Sullivan had publicly vowed that he would never book Elvis Presley. He considered the young singer’s onstage gyrations indecent and sought to keep his show above the hysteria. 

The Ratings Decide

That reticence lasted until Presley’s July, 1956, appearance on The Steve Allen Show drew higher ratings The Ed Sullivan Show. Sullivan came to the light and signed Elvis to a three-show contract worth a then-staggering $50,000 (more than half a million in 2026 dollars) — the largest sum ever paid to a single performer for a television engagement.

The first Sullivan appearance was arranged for September 9, 1956. Sullivan himself was recuperating from a serious auto accident, so the show that night was hosted from New York by actor Charles Laughton.

After Loughton’s introduction from New York, the screen cut to a set in Hollywood, where the audience screams as Elvis comes onstage in a plaid jacket with his leather-clad Martin acoustic guitar. After a few words of gratitude, the band launches into Don’t Be Cruel. He follows with the ballad Love Me Tender, a preview of his first movie. Later came Ready Teddy and Hound Dog, complete with the moves that had alarmed America’s moral guardians.

______________________________


Elvis Preslsey’s first appearance on The Ed Sullivan Show
September 9, 1956

______________________________

Ed Sullivan himself was back in his familiar spot at CBS Studio 50 ⁠2when Elvis made his second appearance on  October 28, 1956.  Before a nationwide audience of nearly 57 million viewers Elvis performed Don’t Be Cruel, Love Me Tender, Hound Dog, and Love Me. At Sullivan’s behest, Elvis toned down his stage movements but the charisma and appeal remained – especially to screaming teen girls. Some of the press grudgingly admitted that the boy could sing, but the country’s moral watchdogs continued to denounce his “contortions” and “jungle rhythms” for corrupting America’s youth.

________________________


Elvis performs Hound Dog October 28, 1956

________________________

The third appearance aired on January 6, 1957. By this time Elvis hysteria had become such a national  controversy that Sullivan insisted the cameras frame Elvis only from the waist up. That night he sang Hound Dog, Don’t Be Cruel, Love Me Tender, and When My Blue Moon Turns to Gold Again.

Then Elvis revealed a quieter, almost plaintive side of his character  when he dipped into his gospel repertoire for a reverent rendering of Peace in the Valley to close out the show.  

________________________


Ed Sullivan, Peace In The Valley, and “a decent, fine boy” named Elvis

________________________

The limited camera angles served to amplify the stately power of Presley’s voice. His third and final appearance on The Ed Sullivan Show again reached more than 50 million viewers, cementing Presley’s dominance of both music, television, and film for the two decades that followed. 

A “Decent, fine boy” 

By the end of his three appearances, Ed Sullivan’s personal ambivalence toward Elvis Presley eased into genuine admiration. Regardless of the controversy around his pelvic antics, Sullivan could see the  sincerity and artistic integrity that drove the spectacle.  After the final performance, Sullivan greeted Presley onstage and told the audience that Elvis Presley was “a real decent, fine boy.” 

In the months that followed his Sullivan triumph, Elvis Presley became the most famous entertainer in the world. Between 1956 and 1958 he released a string of number-one singles, starred in hit films like Love Me Tender and Jailhouse Rock, and with the carnival touch of his manager Colonel Tom Parker spurred a merchandising frenzy unmatched in American pop culture. 

By the time he was drafted into the U.S. Army in March 1958, Elvis Presley had sold more than 25 million records, turned rock ‘n roll into an international language. His success blurred the lines between race, class, and youth in ways that demonstrated television’s capacity to shift American culture at the same time it reflected it. 

________________________

New York Yankees stars Whitey Ford, Yogi Berra, Mickey Mantle & Bill “Moose”  Skowron appeared on the Ed Sullivan Show on April, 13, 1958 to sing Take Me Out To The Ballgame with the song’s composer, Jack Norworth.

________________________

Ed Sullivan continued presiding over Sunday nights as America’s master of ceremonies. From The Beatles to The Supremes, from Topo Gigio to Señor Wences, his stage became a  showcase of shifting tastes and cultural tides. Though his personal style remained stiff, even awkward, his instincts never failed him. For nearly a quarter century, his show was where America went to see its best self.

The final episode of The Ed Sullivan Show aired on Sunday June 6, 1971, after which the show was cancelled by CBS.  After a  23-year run that began as Toast of the Town in 1948, Sullivan was stunned by the network’s decision, but remained with CBS as a special host and presenter for the remainder of his years. 

Ed Sullivan died on October 13, 1974 – fittingly, a Sunday – at the age of 73. 

_______________________________

1 That night’s show drew an estimated 60 million viewers, representing about 82 percent of the television audience — unprecedented for any program up to that point. It eclipsed even the massive ratings of Milton Berle’s and Steve Allen’s earlier Elvis appearances, and it helped solidify Sullivan’s show as the national stage for pop culture.

Later broadcasts (like the Beatles’ debut in 1964, which reached around 73 million viewers) would surpass it, but in 1956, Elvis set the all-time record and confirmed that Sunday nights on CBS were where America went to see what was new, shocking, and unforgettable.

2 CBS Studio 50, on Broadway at  West 53rd Street, was renamed The Ed Sullivan Theater in 1955, at the height of Sullivan’s popularity. The 1,200-seat neo-Gothic theater—originally opened in 1927 as the Hammerstein Theater – remained home to The Ed Sullivan Show until its final broadcast in 1971. In later years it became one of television’s most storied addresses: the site of David Letterman’s The Late Show from 1993 to 2015, when Letterman was replaced by Stephen Colbert.

________________________

©2025 Paul Schatzkin

Countdown #62 Read More »

Countdown #63

October 1, 1955

To The Moon, Alice!

[milestone_featured]

_______________________

September 7, 2027, will mark 100 years from the day when electronic television made its first appearance on Earth.  To generate interest in the Centennial,  this website and accompanying podcast are going to Count Down the Top 100 Milestones from the First 100 Years of Television over 100 weeks until September 7, 2027.
________________________

________________________

Herbert John Gleason was born in Brooklyn, New York, on February 26, 1916, to second-generation Irish American parents. His father, Herbert, sold insurance before deserting the family in 1925. That left his mother, Maisie, to support herself as a subway-booth attendant and raise her young son alone in the cold-water tenements of Brooklyn’s Bushwick and Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhoods.⁠1

Maisie’s rambunctious son was a poor student, preferring to spend more time in pool halls and vaudeville houses than at school. He gave up formal education altogether at age 16 when Maisie died in 1932.

As a teenager, Gleason spent his time hustling pool, doing odd jobs around Brooklyn, and hanging out in clubs, soaking up the comics and emcees who could hold a room with just timing and swagger. He performed in local amateur nights until he found steady work in rough-and-tumble clubs up and down the East Coast, learning to read audiences, pace a laugh, and fill a stage with a larger-than-life personality even when he had little material to work with.

Though he was born Herbert John, everyone in Brooklyn knew him as Jack, and as his popularity grew on the club circuit in the 1930s, audiences came to know him as Jackie Gleason. 

Perfect for Television

Jackie Gleason ca. 1950

From the club circuit he graduated to small parts on Broadway and in B-movies; by the 1940s he was doing radio comedy and character roles in Hollywood. But Gleason’s broad comic style proved better suited to the close-up intimacy of the smaller screen of television. In 1950 he took over the DuMont variety show Cavalcade of Stars, where he developed such vivid characters as the champagne-swilling aristocrat Reginald Van Gleason III and the warm but world-weary confidante Joe the Bartender. 

And then Jackie Gleason breathed life into a loudmouthed Brooklyn bus driver named Ralph Kramden.

On October 5, 1951, the blustery Kramden character made his first appearance on Cavalcade of Stars in a sketch called The Honeymooners – with Pert Kelton as Ralph’s beleaguered wife Alice and Art Carney as their neighbor, the New York sewer worker Ed Norton. 

With the arrival of Ralph, Alice, and The Honeymooners, Cavalcade of Stars made Jackie Gleason a sensation on the struggling DuMont network. ⁠2The bigger players sat up and took notice.  

Jackie Gleason as Joe The Bartender

In 1952, CBS lured Gleason away with one of the richest contracts in television – a reported $11,000 a week, which is roughly equivalent to $135,000 per week – $7 million a year – in 2025 dollars.  Throw in a share of the show’s profits that CBS also agreed to, and Jackie Gleason became one of the highest-paid entertainers in America, rivaling even the most famous Hollywood stars.

An Instant Hit

The new Jackie Gleason Show premiered on September 20, 1952, from CBS Studio 50 in Manhattan (now known as The Ed Sullivan Theater) – and it instantly became one of the network’s biggest hits.⁠3  

The show started out with the usual mix of elements: a live orchestra, dancers, monologues, sketches, and recurring characters, all revolving around Gleason’s canny mix of precision and spontaneity. He famously refused to rehearse, preferring instead to rely on instinct and timing. 

In that environment, The Honeymooners evolved into ten- and twenty-minute domestic comedies. Ralph and the sharp-tongued Alice pulled in larger audiences every week, their dialog often punctuated with Ralph threatening to send his wife “to the moon, Alice!” 

For the three seasons that The Jackie Gleason Show aired on CBS – from the fall of 1952 until the spring of 1955 – it sat near the top of the national Nielsen ratings – second only to TV’s biggest hit: I Love Lucy.  

From “The Jackie Gleason Show” ca. 1952

Gleason was convinced that one reason Lucy consistently outranked him was the sheer visual quality of the show. Because of the bargain Desi Arnaz struck with CBS to produce I Love Lucy on 35mm film, every episode looked like a Hollywood movie.⁠4  The Jackie Gleason show looked like, well, television. 

Through friends he’d maintained from his early years with DuMont, Gleason was aware of a development that could not only put his show on a visual parity with Lucy, but could also give him a leg up in preserving the live performance aspect of his comedy. 

The DuMont Electronicam

At DuMont, engineer James L. Caddigan mounted both an Image Orthicon-based live television camera and a 35mm film camera on the same pedestal, arranging them so that they shared a single lens⁠5. The light passing through that lens was split: one path fed the live broadcast, the other was recorded on high quality film stock. 

The resulting camera was a bit of a beast, but two months after DuMont’s “Electronicam” was announced, Gleason put his show on hiatus so that he could focus on developing The Honeymooners into a half-hour sitcom.  DuMont’s hybrid camera was central to his plans. 

Even though I Love Lucy was filmed before a live studio audience, each episode was shot “film style” – the stop-and-start, multi-take method borrowed from feature films.  

Gleason wanted the best of both worlds: he wanted the non-stop spontaneity of a live television broadcast and the flexibility of film editing and distribution.  DuMont’s system was uniquely suited for that purpose. Gleason not only insisted that CBS use three Electronicams, but he arranged for The Honeymooners to be shot at the Adelphi Theater on West 54th Street – a DuMont owned facility. 

The Honeymooners premiered on Saturday, October 1, 1955, at 8:30 PM, with Audrey Meadows replacing Pert Kelton as Alice, Art Carney reprising his role as Ed Norton, and Joyce Randolph joining the cast as Ed’s wife, Trixie. 

Slotting the show at 8:30 on Saturdays was a bold counter programming move by CBS. The thinking behind slating Kramden & Company directly opposite NBC’s highly-rated Perry Como’s Kraft Music Hall  was simple: Como attracted a family audience; Gleason would appeal to the working-class looking for laughs instead of songs.  

The scheduling was daring but didn’t really work out as CBS had hoped. 

The Honeymooners started out on a high note, but its ratings never matched Perry Como’s. According to the Nielsen rankings, The Honeymooners finished #19 overall for the 1955–56 season – respectable, but far below Gleason’s variety show, which had consistently ranked in the Top 10. Perry Como’s Kraft Music Hall remained a consistent Top 5 program through the entire season.   

The “Classic 39”

The Honeymooners was by no means a flop. It drew millions of viewers every week, but its ratings declined steadily into the spring of 1956.  At that point, Gleason was exhausted from the grind of writing, rehearsing, filming and editing a show every week.  Satisfied that the concept had run its course, he pulled the plug after filming only one season of 39 episodes.

Part of what gave those 39 episodes their lasting appeal was the unique hybrid that DuMont’s Electronicam delivered: the original show went out live, offering the stage-bound intimacy that made audiences at home feel like they were looking in on Ralph, Alice, Ed, and Trixie in their natural habitat – a shabby Brooklyn apartment.  But then the film copy was fine-tuned in editing, producing from that one season what has gone down in TV history as The Honeymooners “Classic 39.” 

After Gleason pulled the plug, CBS broadcast reruns of the “Classic 39,” but in syndication the show achieved a degree of cultural immortality. In the  early 1960s, the episodes were sold to local stations around the country, where they ran day-and-night with such ubiquity that The Honeymooners became a permanent fixture of television’s black-and-white afterlife.

Ralph Kramden, bus driver, and the cast of The Honeymooners

Despite canceling himself after just 39 episodes, Gleason kept the legend alive. In 1962, he returned to CBS with a revived Jackie Gleason Show, first from New York and starting in 1964 from Miami Beach, featuring new Honeymooner sketches.⁠6  Over four seasons, the new Honeymooners was broadcast in color, with new actresses in the wives’ roles: Sheila MacRae as Alice Kramden and Jean Kean as Trixie Norton.  The new  installments were longer, and often expanded into hour-long “trip” episodes like “The Kramdens and The Nortons Go to Paris.” It might be hard to imagine Ralph Kramden under the Eiffel Tower, but it’s not hard to imagine Jackie Gleason telling the network, “this is where we’re gonna shoot.” 

In the 1970s, the original cast of Gleason, Meadows, Carney, and Randolph returned for several reunion specials on CBS, including The Honeymooners: The Second Honeymoon (1976) and The Honeymooners Christmas Special (1978).

The very first episodes of The Honeymooners – the sketches that aired on DuMont’s Cavalcade of Stars, and CBS’s The Jackie Gleason Show – were only recorded as “kinescopes” – the industry’s fancy name for aiming a 16mm film camera at a studio monitor. ⁠7These episodes were believed long lost or even destroyed until the 1980s, when they turned up in Gleason’s personal archives in Florida. Syndicated and released on home video, they added more than a hundred new Honeymooners segments, adding another installment to a legend that had lasted far beyond the stand-alone show’s single season. 

Television made him a household name, but his career after The Honeymooners proved there was more to Jackie Gleason than Ralph Kramden’s bluster.  In 1961 he drew on his roots in the pool halls of Brooklyn to deliver an Oscar-worthy performance as Minnesota Fats opposite Paul Newman in The Hustler⁠8.  He alternated between comedy and drama, starring in films such as Gigot (1962), Requiem for a Heavyweight (1962), Papa’s Delicate Condition (1963), and Soldier in the Rain (1963).  From 1977-83 he reached a new level of box office success and fame as Sheriff Buford T. Justice in the Smokey and the Bandit films. 

Jackie Gleason as Minnesota Fats with Paul Newman in “The Hustler”

Though he died in 1987 at the age of 71, the character that Jackie Gleason created in Ralph Kramden became a cultural archetype that has lated for generations.  

Not Just  A Character – An Archetype

By one account, when William Hanna and Joseph Barbera created The Flintstones in 1960, they pitched it as an animated, stone-age adaption of The Honeymooners.  “At the time,” William Hanna said, “The Honeymooners was the most popular show on the air, and for my bill, the funniest. That influenced greatly what we did with The Flintstones.”

The legacy doesn’t stop there.  Among the characters that grew out of the seed planted by Gleason-as-Kramden are Carroll O’Connor’s Archie Bunker (All In the Family, 1971-1979); John Goodman’s Dan Conner (Roseanne, 1988–1997); Ed O’Neill’s Al Bundy (Married… with Children, 1987–1997) and Kevin James’ Doug Heffernan (The King of Queens, 1998–2007). And the archetype continues today in the longest running animated series in television history, The Simpsons. 

There were only 39 episodes of the original Honeymooners, but Archie and Edith Bunker, Dan and Roseanne Connor, Al and Peg Bundy, Doug and Carrie Heffernan, Marge and Homer Simpson – generations of television programming – all owe their cultural lineage to a bombastic bus driver who came out of the pool halls of Brooklyn in the 1930s. 


There are tons of The Honeymooners on YouTube.  Here’s one clip to whet your appetite.

______________________

1 When he was born in 1916, Jackie had an older brother, Clement, who died in 1919, reportedly from meningitis.

2 The rise and fall of the DuMont network is covered in Countdown 64 re: TV coverage of the Army/McCarthy Senate Hearings in 1954, which DuMont and ABC carried gavel-to-gavel.

3 CBS Studio 50 is more familiar to contemporary viewers as The Ed Sullivan Theater – home to The Late Show, first with David Letterman and then with Stephen Colbert until the networks’s new owners put thefranchise out to pasture in May, 2026.

4 Deși Arnaz’s bargain with CBS to produce I Love Lucy on 35mm film was covered in Countdown #72

5 The provenance of the Image Orthicon – and its reliance on Philo Farnsworth’s original 1927 patents, is covered in Countdown #89.

6 In order to entice Jackie Gleason back onto the network, CBS accepted his demand to set him up in his own little TV kingdom outside of New York or Hollywood. By the mid-60s, Gleason had  permanently relocated to Miami Beach, Florida, mostly so he could golf play year-round, so CBS built him a production facility at the Miami Beach Auditorium, where the announcer opened each episode with “From the sun and fun capital of the world — Miami Beach! — it’s The Jackie Gleason Show!”

7 The name “kinescope” is another one of RCA’s imprints on the origins of the television.  The original “kinescope” was an improved cathode ray tube introduced in 1929 and attributed to the same Vladimir Zworykin who still did not have a viable electronic camera tube two years after Farnsworth first successfully tested his Image Dissector. As with RCA’s trademark for the Image Orthicon tube (Milestone #89), the persistence of the term “kinescope” reminds us that the corporate behemoth that was RCA was much better at naming things than actually inventing them.

8 Jackie Gleason was nominated for Best Supporting Actor at the 34th Academy Awards (1962) for his performance as Minnesota Fats in The Hustler. The Oscar that year went to George Chakiris for his role as Bernardo in West Side Story.

________________________

©2025 Paul Schatzkin

Countdown #63 Read More »

Countdown #64

April 22, 1954

“Have You No Sense of Decency?”

[milestone_featured]

_______________________

September 7, 2027, will mark 100 years from the day when electronic television made its first appearance on Earth.  To generate interest in the Centennial,  this website and accompanying podcast are going to Count Down the Top 100 Milestones from the First 100 Years of Television over 100 weeks until September 7, 2027.
________________________

________________________

Television’s ascendant decade was a confusing time in America, defined in equal parts by prosperity and existential dread. 

On the one hand, the Allies’ triumph in World War II put the Great Depression in the rear view mirror of the big, shiny cars Americans were driving off the showroom floors. 

On the other hand, the whole world was wracked with anxiety over the awesome new force that had been unleashed to end the war in Japan, and the spreading realization that Eastern Europe was receding behind  an “Iron Curtain.”

Then, during the summer of 1949, while audiences across the nation were enjoying the first episodes of These Are My Children, Howdy Doody, and The Goldbergs, the Soviet Union detonated its first atomic bomb. The specter of The Bomb and the growing threat of communism combined to create a festering atmosphere for anyone inclined to stoke suspicion.

Communists!

Joseph  McCarthy was an otherwise unremarkable junior U.S. Senator from Wisconsin until February, 1950, when he appeared at a Lincoln Day dinner in Wheeling, West Virginia. During his remarks to the mostly partisan Republican crowd, McCarthy waved  a piece of paper and exclaimed, “I have here in my hand a list of 205 names that were made known to the Secretary of State as being members of the Communist Party and who nevertheless are still working and shaping policy in the State Department.”

Joseph R. McCarthy, finding Communists everywhere!

That there were no such names, or that the number changed as often as McCarthy’s audience, mattered little in the fraught environment of America in the early 1950s.  

But with that declaration and the campaign of accusations that followed, the nation entered the era forever remembered by adding the suffix “-ism” to Joe McCarthy’s last name.

Herblock – March 29,1950 (click to embiggen)

In the  Washington Post on March 29, 1950, cartoonist Herb Block drew a pile of tar buckets labeled McCarthyism⁠2.” The word stuck, and the era had its villain and new word for anti-Communist demagoguery. 

Apart from the occasional editorial cartoon, the press was largely compliant with McCarthy’s rampage. Newspapers and newsreels passively reported his crusade against the “enemy within.” Editors and publishers were equally reluctant to defy a sitting U.S. Senator who wrapped himself in the flag while exposing traitors. The major national dailies like the New York Times, the Chicago Tribune, and the Washington Post mostly reported McCarthy’s charges without any corroboration, lest they also be accused of being “soft on Communism.” 

Radio was complicit, too. By then a mature medium driven by advertising, the still-dominant form of broadcasting was likewise disinclined to challenge McCarthy. Some stations even canceled commentators deemed too liberal or “un-American.”

TV: The New Kid

Television, on the other hand, was still the new kid on the journalistic block, which may account for the medium’s pivotal role in exposing McCarthy’s mendacity. 

The first to pierce the veil was the CBS program See It Now, hosted by Edward R. Murrow, a veteran radio reporter who gained renown for his “This is London” coverage of the Blitz during the War.  

Edward R. Murrow: “We must not confuse dissent with disloyalty.”

On March 9, 1954, Murrow took on McCarthy with footage of the senator’s own speeches.  After seeing for themselves the contradictions in McCarthy’s allegations, some 10 million people – about a third of the country’s TV households – were treated to a closing commentary for the ages, as Murrow reminded his audience of the most American of principles: 

We must not confuse dissent with disloyalty. We must remember always that accusation is not proof, and that conviction depends upon evidence and due process of law.


Murrow confronts McCarthy on See It Now  – March 9, 1954

After Murrow’s televised rebuke, McCarthy demanded equal time, and CBS gave it to him. On April 6, 1954, McCarthy appeared on See It Now, hurling rambling accusations at Murrow for harboring Communist sympathies. The contrast between Murrow’s calm demeanor and McCarthy’s belligerent bloviation only deepened public unease about the senator.

By the time Murrow and McCarthy faced off on CBS, McCarthy was already embroiled in a contentious dispute with an even more formidable institution: the United States Army.  With his typical bombast, McCarthy had accused the service of harboring Communists.  The Army retaliated with charges of its own – that McCarthy and his counsel, Roy Cohn, had sought to secure special treatment for a friend of Cohn’s, G. David Schine, the scion of a wealthy family of hotel and theater chain owners who had recently been drafted into the Army. 

Senate Hearings

The dispute between the Army and McCarthy became so contentious that the Senate Subcommittee on Investigations announced it would hold hearings in April 1954.  Television executives immediately insisted on a place in the chamber for their cameras – a petition without precedent in Congressional history.

By the time of the Murrow broadcasts, Joseph McCarthy was one of the most notorious politicians in the country.  His own hearings into alleged Communist infiltration of the State Department had drawn large radio and newsreel audiences. 

Television executives got a taste for the blood sport of live Congressional proceedings in 1951-52,  when millions of viewers tuned to the Kefauver Crime Committee. As those hearings turned reputed mobsters into household names, the medium turned congressional inquiry into national theater.

Still, broadcasting the Army/McCarthy hearings live to a national audience presented logistical and financial challenges that only two networks were willing to take on. ABC and The DuMont Network – both still struggling to siphon audience share from rivals NBC and CBS – agreed to pool their resources;  they shared cameras and crews, and split the cost of transmission lines in order to provide uninterrupted coverage.  The arrangement was an unprecedented act of cooperation between commercial rivals – and the first time Congressional proceedings of such critical interest were carried gavel-to-gavel nationwide. 

A pivotal moment in the Army/McCarthy hearings – and, indeed, in American history – was televised on June 9, 1954. While an audience of roughly 20 million people watched, the Army’s lead counsel, Joseph N. Welch, engaged McCarthy in a line of questions when the senator responded by accusing Fred Fisher – a young attorney in Welch’s firm – of Communist ties. 

Welch erupted, “Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?”


Joseph Welch: “At long last, have you no sense of decency?”

The hearing room fell silent as McCarthy shrank under the bright light of Welch’s dignified fury. Finally, the whole nation could see that the anti-Communist crusader was just a narcissistic bully.

McCarthy never recovered. 

The two networks carried the Army/McCarthy hearings  for 8 weeks from late April until mid-June, 1954.  The daily coverage typically ran 6 to 7 hours four or five days each week and sometimes even on Saturday mornings.  By the end, the two networks had broadcast roughly 187 hours of live testimony – while NBC and CBS continued with their regular daytime programming offering only highlights in their nightly newscasts. 

Six months after the hearings, on December 2, the Senate censured McCarthy by a vote of 67 to 22  for conduct “contrary to senatorial traditions.” Stripped of his committee chairmanship and shunned by colleagues and press alike, McCarthy retreated from public life. He made only perfunctory appearances until May 2, 1957, when he died from complications of alcohol-related hepatitis at just 48 years of age. 

The Rise and Fall of DuMont

Despite the impact of its coverage, The DuMont network did not fare much better.

Allen B. Dumont and one of his Cathode Ray Tubes

Allen B. DuMont was one of television’s true pioneers. In the 1920s, the self-taught engineer took an interest in cathode-ray tubes, which at the time were still notoriously cranky and unreliable. While working at De Forest Radio Company, DuMont developed better vacuum seals, phosphor coatings, and manufacturing processes to make the tubes more dependable. 

In 1931, he founded the Allen B. DuMont Laboratories in Passaic, New Jersey, and found steady business building CRTs for oscilloscopes, which became indispensable electronic instruments during the 1930s.  That success supplied the expertise and the capital to produce television picture tubes.  As early as 1938 the DuMont company was selling some of the first practical home television receivers in America.

DuMont’s technical footing in CRT production let him to expand vertically: from tubes to complete TV sets, and then to programming. In 1946 he launched the DuMont Television Network, and offered coast-to-coast broadcasts in 1951 –  the same year as NBC. Though chronically under-funded and short on affiliates, the DuMont Network became a proving ground for television talent and innovation, which culminated in its coverage of the Army-McCarthy hearings.

Despite its pioneering efforts, DuMont was always the fourth network in a market barely large enough for three.  Without a broad base of profitable radio affiliates,  DuMont struggled to secure advertisers and expand.  The continuous coverage of the 1954 hearings was the peak of the network’s reach, but by 1955, DuMont had curtailed most of its original programming.⁠3 

By 1956 the network ceased operations entirely, marking the end of a pioneering entry in both the hardware and software that had made television the indispensable medium by the end of the decade. 


This short documentary traces the history of the DuMont Network

____________________

1 That’s the canonical version, though no official transcript survives. The text was reconstructed from reporters’ notes, since McCarthy didn’t release a written copy of his remarks.

2 The suffix “-ism” itself goes back centuries, used in English since at least the 1600s to denote systems of thought — Calvinism, Marxism, socialism, communism, fascism, and so on. But those earlier isms referred to coherent ideologies or philosophical systems.

What was novel about “McCarthyism” – coined in 1950, only weeks after McCarthy’s Wheeling speech—was that it described not a philosophy but a behavioral pattern: guilt by association, reckless accusation, and the weaponization of fear for political gain.

3 Another structural factor that contributed to DuMont’s demise was a freeze the FCC imposed on licensing and spectrum allocation – first imposed in 1948 and not lifted until 1952 – which restricted the number of VHF channel assignments available in key markets. NBC and CBS already held the most valuable frequencies, relegating DuMont  to weaker UHF channels, which required special tuners and reached far fewer viewers.

________________________

©2025 Paul Schatzkin

Countdown #64 Read More »

Countdown #65

January 1, 1954

In Living Color

[milestone_featured]

_______________________

September 7, 2027, will mark 100 years from the day when electronic television made its first appearance on Earth.  To generate interest in the Centennial,  this website and accompanying podcast are going to Count Down the Top 100 Milestones from the First 100 Years of Television over 100 weeks until September 7, 2027.
________________________

________________________

By the start of 1954, the United States was home to about 160 million people living in 48 million households. Some 27 million of those households  – roughly 55% – had at least one television set.

What none of them had, however, was any kind of color TV. 

That anybody would even think that television could be anything other than black-and-white came from the movies. Color had been part of the motion picture experience as early as the 1890s, when individual film frames were hand-painted or dipped in colored dye baths. Prints of Georges Méliès’ landmark 1902 film A Trip to the Moon were often colorized this way.

_______________________________


George Méliès’ Le Voyage Dan La Lune in restored color
_______________________________

Early attempts at actual color film date back to the 1910s, but the first process that really worked was Technicolor’s “Process 4,” ⁠1 which used three separate strips of film to produce rich, realistic hues.  When Walt Disney used the process for his short film, Flowers and Trees in 1932, it was an immediate hit and won an Oscar. Technicolor reached its pre-war zenith with the release of The Wizard of Oz and Gone With The Wind in late 1939. 

By the mid 1950s, nearly half of the feature films coming out of Hollywood were in color. That gave the film industry a temporary advantage over the new kid on every block, but also raised expectations that television, too, would eventually be delivered in something other than shades of grey.  But the process of delivering television in color would prove to be one of the most daunting engineering challenges of the mid-century. 

The First Attempts 

Experiments with color television date back to the first successful experiments with mechanical scanning.  As early as 1928, Britain’s John Logie Baird demonstrated a color system that used a Nipkow disc with with red, green, and blue filters.  In the U.S., Bell Labs pioneer Dr. Herbert Ives conducted experiments in the late 1920s and early 1930s with a system that used three photoelectric cells for the red, green, and blue signals. 

These early experiments illustrate the first challenge of color TV: In much the same way that television required breaking an image into individual elements, the spectrum of colors also needed to be separated into its three primary hues – red, green, and blue. But once the standards for monochrome television were set, colorizing video had to overcome at least three further obstacles. 

First, a whole new kind of television camera would have to be invented.  From the advent of Farnsworth’s Image Dissector in the 1920s and 30s through the adoption of the Image Orthicon in the 1940s and 50s, television cameras required only a single tube to convert an image into an electrical signal.⁠2 Color would require at least three – one each for the red, green, and blue primary colors.  In the 1940s, engineers at RCA, GE and Philco experimented with prisms and mirrors to separate the light into three separate tubes. The first such cameras were bulky, finicky, and demanded intense lighting, but established the principle that color television began at the lens.  

Second, if cameras could be engineered to generate a color signal, then receivers had to be reinvented to display it. Black-and-white requires only a single phosphor coating on the picture tube; color requires three – for the red, green, and blue – and a way to aim the electron beams so they strike only their intended color target.  

Back to Spinning Wheels 

At CBS in the 1940s, engineer and inventor Peter Goldmark tried to clear this hurdle with a throwback to the mechanical systems of the 1920s. Called the “field-sequential” color system, Goldmark placed a spinning wheel of color filters in front of an ordinary black-and-white picture tube, and the electron beam alternated color elements in sequence according to the synchronized color filter. 

Peter Goldmark and the “color wheel” that CBS tried to make standard

Goldmark’s system was innovative and relatively successful, but was hampered by the third issue facing any approach to color television: compatibility.  Any system that offered color was going to have to work with the millions of televisions consumers had already spent billions of dollars (and pounds, and francs and marks and yen) on.  

Goldmark’s system produced images that were sharp and vivid in color, but could not be replicated at all on existing receivers. Novel and effective as it was, Goldmark’s system was doomed while the industry looked for a system that could weave color into the signal in a way that existing television sets would continue to show a normal picture. ⁠3

CBS Color Wheel Camera

While experimenting continued apace, Goldmark’s system was perfected to the point that the FCC adopted it as the U.S. color television standard on October 11, 1950. ⁠4 

Not So Fast! 

But at RCA, David Sarnoff did not accept that decision as any kind of final. He immediately declared that “RCA will never allow this counterfeit scheme to be foisted on the American people.” Given the vast corporate resources at its command, it comes as no surprise that RCA made good on Sarnoff’s promise. 

RCA spent several million dollars per year on color R&D at its laboratory in Princeton, New Jersey.  By 1952, the investment paid off with an all-electronic system that wove color information into the existing black-and-white signal so seamlessly that older sets without color simply ignored it.

Much of the individual credit for developing the RCA color system has been attributed to George H. Brown, who, along with Albert Rose and Richard C. Webb, figured out how to fit the color information into the same 6-MHz channel used for monochrome broadcasts.  That meant that the color signal could be seen as black-and-white on the millions of receivers already sitting in living rooms around the country (and the world). 

The New Color Standard… 

Once the technical hurdles were cleared, RCA took its case to the National Television System Committee – the same industry consortium that approved the 525-line / 30-frame standard that consolidated the industry in 1941.⁠5  In July 1953, The NTSC submitted its recommendations – based entirely on RCA’s system – to the FCC.  Just three years after approving it, the Commission set aside Goldmark/CBS standard, and adopted the RCA-developed NTSC Color Standard on December 17, 1953.

Two weeks later, on New Year’s Day 1954, the RCA-owned NBC network broadcast the Tournament of Roses Parade in what was promoted as the first coast-to-coast color broadcast. From Pasadena, California, NBC’s cameras captured the flower-festooned floats in hues never before seen on a television screen. 

_________________________

To have color footage of the Rose Parade telecast, NBC would have needed to make a color “kinescope” 16mm from a studio monitor. If such footage exists, it is not to be found on the Internet. Here instead is what appears to be direct 16mm color film of the actual event.
_________________________

But for the most part, all those vivid colors were still seen only in shades of grey. 

RCA’s first color television – the RCA CT-100 – did not even go on sale until December 31, 1953 – the day before the Rose Parade broadcast.  The new color unit was priced at $1,000 (about $12,000 in 2026 dollars) and trade reports from the period suggest that there were none in private use prior to the New Year’s parade.  The actual color was available only on demonstration sets at NBC affiliates, department stores, and showrooms were people could view the colorcast. In fact, RCA didn’t really start manufacturing the CT-100 until March, 1954. 

…But Still Mostly Shades of Grey

The RCA CT-100

Programming on all the networks remained mostly black-and-white for another decade, and even by the mid 1960s color sets were found in fewer than 10% of American households. 

Nevertheless, David Sarnoff took credit for introducing color television in 1954 just as he had taken credit for introducing black-and-white television at the New York World’s Fair in 1939. Sarnoff himself famously described RCA’s color initiative as the company’s “second invention of television” – a corporate conceit that neatly sidestepped who really invented it the first time. 

NBC promoted the Rose Parade as a broadcast “brought to you in color.” RCA and NBC were mainly focused on selling RCA color TV sets, so the ads emphasized “See it on RCA Victor Color Television.”

In 1957, NBC began introducing its color programs with the slogan “The following program is brought to you in living color,” accompanied by an animated peacock logo spreading its tail feathers in a rainbow of colors.  The peacock remained part of NBCs logo for decades to come, and “Peacock” is the name that NBC – by then owned by the Comcast cable TV conglomerate – adopted for its video streaming service when it went online in 2020. 

_________________________

1 Called Technicolor #4 because there were three prior iterations of Technicolor first tested in 1916, 1922 and 1925. The process used to shoot The Wizard of Oz and Gone With The Wind employed three separate strips of black-and-white film that were simultaneously exposed through red, green, and blue filters and then combined in printing to produce the final color image. It was an expensive and cumbersome process requiring a massive, proprietary camera, but the results were lush and vivid in a way that made both films showcases for the technology.

2 The provenance of the Image Orthicon camera tube – and its origins in Farnsworth’s patents – was discussed in Milestone #89, Eye Can See Clearly Now.

3 Peter Goldmark’s approach to color TV was ultimately consigned to the dustbin of tech history, but he is remembered for one far more lasting contribution to technology and culture. In the 1940s he developed the Long Playing (LP) 33-1/3 recording, which introduced high fidelity sound and became a staple of the recording industry in the 1950s and 60s. He also invented a record player for automobiles which was considerably less successful.

4 Goldmark’s sequential color system was not the only early attempt at color TV.  

In Mexico, the engineer and inventor Guillermo González Camarena received U.S. Patent #2,296,019 in 1942 for a color television system he called the “Chromascope.”  Using a field-sequential approach similar to the Goldmark/CBS system, González Camarena demonstrated his system with the first color transmission in Mexico in 1946 – years before color broadcasting became a commercial reality in the U.S. 

And in the U.S., no less a luminary than Ernest O. Lawrence – Nobel Laureate, veteran of The Manhattan Project and inventor of the first cyclotron atom-smasher –  patented a color system in 1951 called the Chromatron.  Also known at “the Lawrence Tube” the Chromatron was never commercially viable, but aspects of its technology found their way in to the Sony Trinitron, one of the most popular consumer electronics products ever manufactured.

5 The process of arriving at national signal standards for television broadcasting was addressed in Milestone #91, “Standards. “

________________________

©2025 Paul Schatzkin

Countdown #65 Read More »

Countdown #66

October 10, 1953

Hey Kids, You Can Play Along At Home! 

[milestone_featured]

_______________________

September 7, 2027 will mark 100 years from the day when electronic television made its first appearance on Earth.  To generate interest in the Centennial,  this website and accompanying podcast are going to Count Down the Top 100 Milestones from the First 100 Years of Television over 100 weeks until September 7, 2027.
________________________

________________________

Three decades before Steve Jobs ever saw a mouse or Bill Gates ever peered through a window, there was… Winky Dink. ⁠1

If you grew up with smart phones and video games, it might be hard to fathom how kids in the 1950s interacted with their televisions: by drawing directly on the screen with crayons. 

No, we didn’t draw directly on the surface of the cathode ray tube (at least, not if we wanted to live long enough to see another cartoon). What we did was place a sheet of transparent vinyl over the screen – and draw on that.  

The Magic Screen

When the first episode of Winky Dink and You aired on CBS on October 10, 1953, host Jack Barry⁠2 urged the kids in the audience (with their parents’ help, of course) to send away for the Winky Dink Kit, so that they could assist the show’s characters in their escapades.  

The address was flashed on the screen – “Send 50¢ to Winky Dink, CBS-TV, New York” – and the network followed up with cross promotions in TV-Guide. After the first few weeks, the kit was offered at local toy and department stores when the mail-order system alone couldn’t keep up with the demand.

Original issue Winky Dink Kits can be found on eBay and Etsy

For their half-a-buck (about $6 in 2026), kids received a colorful box. Inside was a clear vinyl sheet, a “magic cloth”  that caused the vinyl to adhere to the TV screen with static electricity, and several “magic crayons” to draw on the vinyl with. 

Winky Dink and You was created by Edwin Brit Wyckoff, a writer and producer with experience in children’s media, and Jack Schlein, a production manager at CBS.  Their concept was as ingenious as the production was primitive. 

The central character of the show was Winky Dink, a wide-eyed, squeaky-voiced cartoon boy.  The animators created illustrations with blank spaces timed to cues in the story. In the course of his comic adventures, when Winky came to a river he needed to cross, or a wall he needed to get through, he would stop and turn to his viewers for help. 

“Get out your Winky Dink screen!” Winky said. 

And then millions of kids were instructed draw a bridge across the riverbanks or a door through the wall with their magic crayons onto the magic screen stuck to their TVs. 

And after sufficient pause, the animation would continue, with Winky proceeding as if the children’s doodles had truly become part of his cartoon world. 

Probably not something you’d want to do on today’s LCD or OLED displays

The illusion was simple but effective. By combining simple animation with on-screen prompts, Wyckoff and Schlein demonstrated that the new medium could be more than a passive diversion. For the first time the kids who were raised on TV were invited to become part of the story.

Some estimates put the number of Winky Dink kits sold across the country at around 2 million, with a peak audience of 10 million children tuning in each week.  CBS regarded Winky Dink as one of the first successful bits of direct television merchandising: it wasn’t just a toy tie-in, it was essential to the show’s function, which made uptake unusually high for a kids’ program.

Winky Dink and You ran on CBS Saturday mornings from 1953 to 1957. Unfortunately. within its genius lay the twin seeds of its demise.  

First, though they could somehow afford the seeming extravagance of a television set in the 1950s, there were countless families who could not afford the additional fifty cents (later a whole dollar) for the Wink Dink Kit.  Those kids just drew directly on the TV screen with their own not-so-magic crayons, no doubt causing apoplexy for their parents.  And there was growing concern that by sitting close enough to the screen to draw on it, kids might be exposed to harmful radiation from the CRT. 

A Glimpse of the Distant Future 

It is tempting to dismiss Winky Dink as a gimmick from the early years of TV, but it should also be regarded as the first indication of what video could ultimately deliver.  

The idea that a viewer might become a user, was as radical in the 1950s as it is commonplace today.  It is no exaggeration to say that Winky Dink and You presaged the ubiquity of interactive media decades before joysticks, keyboards, touchscreens, or hyperlinks.  The kid-doodled bridges and doors of Winky Dink in the 1950s foreshadowed the paddles of Pong in 1972, the avatars of Pac-Man in 1980, and the cursor clicks of the World Wide Web in the 1990s.

The first interactive video controller

The physical act of drawing on the screen suggested that television could be more than an impenetrable glass panel; it could also be a window through which things could be layered and manipulated.  

Perhaps most notably, Winky Dink offers a novel example of the 1950s spirit of experimentation with a medium looking to find its own forms. Winky Dink proved that kids would engage eagerly with interactive elements, foreshadowing the participatory ethos of children’s programming from Blue’s Clues to Dora the Explorer. More profoundly, it demonstrated that audiences wanted to do more than watch; they wanted to play.

After Winky Dink experienced a brief revival in the 1960s, the concept reappeared with the plastic overlays for early home consoles like the Magnavox Odyssey in the early 1970s, which came with static overlays for Pong-like games. By then, educational television had shifted to programs like Sesame Street, and truly interactive video games were just around the corner. 

Industry veterans and cultural historians often cite Winky Dink as “the first interactive television program.” Indeed, no less an authority than Microsoft founder Bill Gates⁠3 has cited Winky Dink as the seminal example of interactive TV and the first direct forerunner of the interactive digital-and-video world of the 21st Century.


Watch an episode of Winky Dink & You on YouTube

________________________

1 The “mouse” interface was first developed at the Xerox Palo Alto Research Center (PARC), where Steve Jobs was famously inspired to adapt it to the first Apple Macintosh with its Graphical User Interface (GUI). Microsoft followed suit with Windows, sparking a years-long dispute over the “look and feel” of the MacOS -v- MS Windows.

2 Original Winky Dink host Jack Barry (1918–1984) is better remembered for his role in 1950s quiz shows. Along with his producing partner Dan Enright, Barry created and hosted programs like Twenty-One and Tic-Tac-Dough. Both men became central figures in the late-1950s quiz show scandals, when it was revealed that contestants had been secretly coached to produce more dramatic television. Barry’s career collapsed in 1959, and he spent much of the next decade in obscurity before returning in the 1960s and eventually reviving his standing with The Joker’s Wild in the 1970s.

3 In an article posted in 2013, CNN Contributor Bob Greene tracked down Gates’ personal spokesman John Pinette, who recalled a speech where Gates cited Winky Dink as “an early example of interactive TV.”  Pinette also recalled that Gates owned one of the 1950s Winky Dink kits, still in its original box. 

________________________

©2025 Paul Schatzkin

Countdown #66 Read More »

Countdown #67

April 3, 1953

What’s On The TeeVee Tonight?

[milestone_featured]

_______________________

September 7, 2027 will mark 100 years from the day when electronic television made its first appearance on Earth.  To generate interest in the Centennial,  this website and accompanying podcast are going to Count Down the Top 100 Milestones from the First 100 Years of Television over 100 weeks until September 7, 2027.
________________________

________________________

Walter Annenberg’s impact on television did not stop with the low budget “sock hop” that premiered on his TV station in Philadelphia in 1952. 

Quite the contrary.  

But the biggest thing that Annenberg did for television was not even on television.

It was in print – in a pocket-sized weekly magazine called TV Guide. 

Despite his company’s forays into broadcasting, Annenberg was first and foremost a publisher – the business he had inherited from his father.  His first instinct was toward what he could do in print, but the idea for a magazine filled with little more than television listings did not start in-house. 

The first issue of The TeleVision Guide

In New York, Lee Wagner – the former circulation director for MacFadden Publications  – recognized the growing appetite for television schedules in the late 1940s. On June 14, 1948, working in concert with Cowles Media, Wagner published the first issue of The TeleVision Guide, a pocket-sized folio of New York–area listings. The debut issue featured a cover photo of former film star Gloria Swanson, who was at the time hosting a variety program on WPIX-TV, one of the city’s unaffiliated local stations. Wagner soon expanded with regional editions for New England and the Baltimore-Washington corridor, proving there was a market for a dedicated guide.

We’re Gonna Need a Map

In Philadelphia, Walter Annenberg observed the same phenomenon. In 1948, his Triangle Publications invested in TV Digest, a small weekly that provided program listings for the Philadelphia market. What began as a local experiment quickly grew popular, demonstrating that television required a printed road map to navigate its expanding program grid.

By 1953, with televisions having found their way into more than half of America’s households, Annenberg decided to scale the concept nationally. Rather than compete with Wagner’s regional editions, he acquired them outright and folded them into the Triangle empire. Both Wagner and Annenberg had proven that the concept worked in a few markets, but Annenberg had the capital and marketing savvy to create a single national publication with countless regional editions. 

The first issue of Triangle Publications’ TV Guide appeared on newsstands in ten major cities on April 3, 1953.  On its cover, 1.5 million readers were treated to a close-up photo of newly born Desi Arnaz, Jr. Television had become such an intimate thread in the cultural fabric that all of America was invited to gush over a sitcom couple’s actual baby.

The First Fall Preview

The first “Fall Preview” edition of TV Guide

Later that year, for the September 26-to-October 2, 1953 edition,  TV Guide published its first “Fall Preview” issue, establishing a cultural cycle that would last for decades. Until that point, the networks tended to launch their new shows whenever they were ready. TV Guide helped establish the annual ritual of launching a whole new “season” of programs every autumn. Advertisers and networks seized on the Fall Preview as an opportunity to promote both new and returning shows.  With its blend of listings and editorial content, TV Guide assumed an exalted role as the national authority on the medium.

Over the years that followed, TV Guide expanded market by market, tailoring each edition to local channel lineups. By 1955, the magazine covered nearly every market in the country, effectively becoming as firmly entrenched as television itself. By the mid-1960s, TV Guide was publishing more than 140 localized editions, reaching more than 10 million readers each week. By the mid-1970s, its circulation climbed to nearly 20 million. 

Prior to TV Guide, the most popular magazine in America was Reader’s Digest, a publication that condensed the nation’s reading habits into bite-sized pieces. When  TV Guide surpassed the Digest in circulation in the mid-1960s, America was no longer a nation of readers. It was a nation of viewers. 

A Man of Wealth and Taste

The instinct that compelled the launch of TV Guide made Walter Annenberg one of the richest men in America, and he leveraged that wealth in both politics and philanthropy.  In 1969, he was named U.S. Ambassador to the Court of St. James’s, serving as Nixon’s envoy to Britain. In later years, he donated billions to schools, museums, and the arts. His gifts have funded institutions like the Annenberg School for Communication at the Universities of Pennsylvania and Southern California. 

Leonore and Walter Annenberg ca. 1970s

Thanks largely to TV Guide, Walter Annenberg was consistently listed among the Forbes 400 wealthiest Americans. In 1988, he sold Triangle Publications to Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation in a deal that was valued at $3 billion. 

Walter Annenberg’s ascent to the highest echelons of American society started with the publications he inherited from his father.  He added electronic media and played a critical role in the growth of television – starting with a low-budget dance show in Philadelphia. When he died in 2002, at the age of 94, he’d built one of the great fortunes in the world, not with broadcasting, but with a pocket-sized weekly that told America, every night, what was on. 

________________________

©2025 Paul Schatzkin

Countdown #67 Read More »

Countdown #68

October 7, 1952

Spinning The Hits

[milestone_featured]

_______________________

September 7, 2027, will mark 100 years from the day when electronic television made its first appearance on Earth.  To generate interest in the Centennial,  this website and accompanying podcast are going to Count Down the Top 100 Milestones from the First 100 Years of Television over 100 weeks until September 7, 2027.
________________________

________________________

When 16-year-old Ricky Nelson made his teen-idol debut on TV in April 1957, he sharpened a trend that actually started forming about the same time the Nelson family started appearing in America’s living rooms in 1952.

It was certainly not lost on the networks – or their customers, the advertisers – that among those families that were gathered around the cool glow of the electronic hearth were millions of impressionable children. And some of those children – born in the late 1930s and early ’40s – were becoming a generation of teenagers unlike any before them.  

Gathering around the TV with the family was a thing in the 1950s

As kids, they had endured the same wartime austerity as their parents, but as they came of age, the booming postwar economy put more spending money in their pockets than their parents ever had at the same age. Allowances were more common;  part-time jobs were plentiful in shops, diners, and gas stations. And their parents were eager to give them the things they themselves had gone without during the Depression. 

Enter Walter Annenberg

The 1950s generation of teens was the first raised entirely within the flux of television’s magnetic field—a generation whose style, language, and identity was shaped by their uniquely common experience.

Advertisers salivated at the prospect: a whole new market, ripening on the vine and ready to harvest. 

Those kids found an unlikely advocate – and the advertisers found a savvy ally – in Walter Annenberg, the heir to a publishing empire with a keen eye for underserved markets. 

Walter Annenberg ca. 1960

Annenberg inherited The Philadelphia Inquirer after the death of his father, Moses Annenberg in 1942⁠1 and immediately set about expanding the business into other media. In 1947, he acquired Philadelphia’s flagship radio stations, WFIL-AM and WFIL-FM.  After rolling all the assets into a company called Triangle Publications, he added WFIL-TV in 1948, which became affiliated with the fledgling ABC network. 

Annenberg first anticipated the youth market in 1944, when he invited former Mademoiselle editor Helen Valentine to create Seventeen magazine, which she designed specifically to cater to the interests of teenage girls.  Then in 1952, WFIL-TV program director Lew Klein, looking to fill a dead afternoon time slot, proposed a show aimed at the heart of the postwar teen market 

The concept behind Bandstand  was simple: local radio personality Bob Horn spun the latest hit records while well-dressed teenagers in the studio danced to them. The format cost next to nothing to produce and was endlessly renewable, with a fresh supply of chart-toppers ever month and new cast of teenagers every year.

After its debut on October 7, 1952, the televised sock hop caught on slowly; local popularity didn’t automatically translate into a green light from the network. Despite the low-budget formula, ABC executives were leery of teen-oriented programming, and advertisers needed convincing that rock ‘n’ roll was anything other than a subversive fad.  

America’s Oldest Teenager

It didn’t help when Bob Horn had to be fired in 1956 amid a drunk-driving arrest and accusations involving underage girls. ⁠2That’s when 26-year-old WFIL staff announcer Dick Clark took over. 

Dick Clark took over WFIL-TVs American Bandstand in 1957

Clean-cut and ambitious, Clark spent a year putting his mark on the concept. Seeking to build Bandstand’s after-school appeal, he courted record companies, advertisers and, ultimately, ABC network executives. He kept pitching Bandstand  as a wholesome, sponsor-friendly way to reach America’s growing teen demographic. 

In the mid-1950s ABC was still the perennial third network behind NBC and CBS in the both ratings and prestige when the pieces finally fell into place:  The new host had polished the format, rock ‘n’ roll had demonstrated its broadening appeal, and ABC needed a cheap, youth-oriented hit.  

In the spring of 1957, when the network asked its affiliates for ideas to fill 3:30 PM slot, WFIL’s Bandstand fit the bill. Clark would later credit network president Thomas W. Moore for putting the live, daily feed on the network from Philadelphia. 

At 3:30 PM on August 5, 1957, American Bandstand beamed out on 67 ABC affiliates, kicking off with Jerry Lee Lewis’s Whole Lotta Shakin’ Goin’ On.

Within weeks, the after-school dance party had proven it could move both feet and numbers. Ratings climbed steadily as word spread among kids from coast to coast. Sponsors like Beech-Nut Gum, 7-Up, RC Cola, and Clearasil — once reluctant to embrace rock ’n’ roll — now saw a direct pipeline to a lucrative new market. And the languishing network finally had a daily hit that didn’t cost a fortune to produce.

A Persistent Problem

The host himself proved an avid spokesman, often smiling straight into the camera between songs and reminding the audience, “You know, Beech-Nut’s got a flavor for everybody – peppermint, spearmint, and that smooth, cool wintergreen. Whichever you pick, you’ll be the one with the freshest breath on the dance floor.”

Dancing on Bandstand ca. 1955

But behind the gum-peddling host and the sweater-clad couples, another story simmered. The same production values that made American Bandstand safe for national advertisers also revealed the fault lines of a country redefining its postwar political and cultural landscapes. 

More than any prior conflict or period of American history, World War II brought unprecedented numbers of Black soldiers, sailors and airmen into service alongside their white contemporaries – many of whom remained reluctant to accept their comrades as peers.  When the war finally ended, that genie was not going back in the bottle; to the contrary, the trend toward racial integration continued – perhaps starting in earnest when Army veteran Jackie Robinson took the field for the Brooklyn Dodgers in the spring 1947.

In the years between Jackie Robinson and Bandstand, blues and R&B artists like Fats Domino and The Platters were already crossing onto the pop charts. And young audiences – Black and white – found common ground on the dance floor before it was reflected on their TV screens.

When Bandstand went national, the landscape began to shift beneath the gyrating feet of the next generation, and it became clear that music — especially music on television – would play a role in reshaping the character of the nation.

Dick Clark and Little Richard ca. 1963

Perhaps not surprisingly, one of the first nationally aired episodes broke the color barrier with an appearance by Black recording artist Billy Williams, performing his 1957 hit I’m Gonna Sit Right Down and Write Myself a Letter.  Williams was a suitable choice because his mostly non-rock repertoire – already familiar to mainstream audiences – made him acceptable to the still mostly segregated TV audience.  

Over the following years, countless popular Black entertainers were featured on American Bandstand: Fats Domino performed his hits Blueberry Hill, and I’m Walkin; The Coasters, Searchin’ and Yakety Yak;  Chuck Berry, School Day; Sam Cooke, You Send Me; and The Platters, Only You and The Great Pretender.⁠3  Even the flamboyant Little Richard found favor with Clark and his dancing teens, though not without controversy in light of his unusual stage presence. 

American Bandstand’s lineup frequently included popular Black recording artists, but the studio audience in Philadelphia remained effectively segregated.  WFIL-TV controlled the distribution of tickets through schools, youth clubs, or individual requests.  That very limited distribution – and informal screening at the studio doors – ensured that the faces seen dancing on camera were mostly white. 

You needed a ticket to get in. It helped if you were also white.

Local civil rights activists, Black teens and their parents, challenged those practices. In response, American Bandstand’s producer, Tony Mammarella, and other WFIL-TV executives petitioned the Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations, testifying in effect, “We’re not discriminating – we just let in whoever gets tickets.”  And while the commission stopped short of issuing a formal finding of statutory discrimination, their report explicitly noted the complete “absence of Negroes from attendance” and hinted that whatever the producers were doing to distribute tickets resulted in a de facto segregated crowd.

The pressure worked, however slowly.  Without any actual acknowledgment from the producers American Bandstand gradually integrated its studio audience over several years . Like much of television in that era, the change was a quiet, subtle concession to a shifting culture.

American Bandstand ran for almost 40 years.  After running locally as Bandstand from 1952 until 1957, the program continued from Philadelphia on the ABC network until 1987, when it relocated to Los Angeles for two more years in syndication. Dick Clark finally handed the microphone to David Hirsch for the show’s last season, ending in October, 1989.

A Viable Alternative

By the early 1970s, the contradictions baked into American Bandstand were impossible to ignore.  Black artists appeared onstage, but Black teenagers remained mostly invisible.  That disparity finally led Chicago impresario Don Cornelius to create Soul Train, a national showcase created by and for Black artists and audiences that started to syndicate nationally in October, 1971.

Don Cornelius (R) was creator, host, and executive producer of Soul Train

Soul Train was more than a Black alternative using the Bandstand template. It was in many ways the obvious successor in a world in which musical expression had broadened far beyond rock, R&B and soul.  Cornelius used his platform to celebrate Black pride, culture, and style in ways network TV rarely did in the early ’70s; He presented artists from James Brown and Aretha Franklin to Prince, Whitney Houston, and Beyoncé (who appeared as part of of the group  Destiny’s Child). 

Soul Train introduced generations to funk, hip hop, and house music.  But despite its emphasis on music with roots somewhere in Black culture, the lineup was never exclusively Black.  Over the years countless white performers were also featured, including Elton John, David Bowie, Hall & Oates, Gino Vanelli and Beck. 

Dick Clark – America’s Oldest Teenager – with the studio audience in 1981

If Bandstand bore the burdens of its era, Soul Train reflected the broadened scope and appeal of American music well into the 21st century. After a run of 35 years, when Soul Train pulled into the station for its last original show in March 2006, it joined American Bandstand — which had ended its 37-year run in 1989 — in the history books as one of television’s most enduring music showcases.

Together, American Bandstand and Soul Train shaped how generations of Americans saw themselves reflected on screen for more than seven decades. The first was transmitted tentatively over the segregated airwaves of the early postwar era; the other was embraced by a far more integrated nation. Both left legacies that long outlived their final broadcasts.

_______________________
Like nearly everything else in the Countdown starting in the 1950s, American Bandstand is all over YouTube.  Here’s a segment with Paul Anka performing live (i.e. lip-sync’ed) in 1959:

 

________________________

1 Moses Annenberg acquired the Inquirer in 1936 but served a prison sentence for tax evasion in 1940, dying shortly after his release in 1942. Walter, then in his mid-30s, took over his father’s publishing empire, which included the Inquirer and the Daily Racing Form.

2 Ironically, Horn’s dismissal came amid a DWI campaign championed by Walter Annenberg’s own flagship property, The Philadelphia Inquirer.

3 If the title I’m Walkin’ appears familiar, that’s because it’s the same song that Ricky Nelson performed when he made his TV singing debut on The Adventures of Ozzie & Harriet in April, 1957.  The song was 

written by Fats Domino and Dave Bartholomew, released in early 1957, and became a hit for Domino that spring.  So, in yet another touch of period irony, when American Bandstand booked Fats Domino in 1957, that was the original artist performing the same song Ricky Nelson had already covered on TV.

________________________

©2025 Paul Schatzkin

Countdown #68 Read More »

Countdown #69

October 3, 1952

America’s Favorite Family

[milestone_featured]

_______________________

September 7, 2027 will mark 100 years from the day when electronic television made its first appearance on Earth.  To generate interest in the Centennial,  this website and accompanying podcast are going to Count Down the Top 100 Milestones from the First 100 Years of Television over 100 weeks until September 7, 2027.
________________________

________________________

By the fall of 1952, just over one-third of America’s 43 million households owned at least one television set—a nearly four-fold increase from the start of the decade. The median family income was roughly $3,900 (about $50,000 in 2026 dollars) and the average cost of a television set was around $200.

In that prosperous postwar moment, as suburbs sprawled and incomes climbed, those millions of households were introduced to the family that would define the white-picket-fence American Dream for years to come: Ozzie and Harriet. 

Originally from Jersey City, New Jersey, Oswald George Nelson was studying the law when he surrendered to the siren of the Jazz Age in the late 1920s and formed the Ozzie Nelson Orchestra. What he lacked in flashy showmanship he made up for with an ear for stylish arrangements and a nose for the booking side of the business. By the mid-1930s, his band was a steady draw on the hotel ballroom circuit and on the radio.

Peggy Lou Snyder, the daughter of vaudeville performers from Des Moines, Iowa, began singing with local bands as a teenager. When she joined the Paul Ash Orchestra and began performing in New York clubs, she adopted the stage name Harriet Hilliard — “Harriet” sounded more sophisticated than “Peggy,” and “Hilliard” was a name her father had used on stage. 

Ozzie and Harriett ca. 1936

Starting in 1930, Harriet landed small roles in such forgettable films as Follow The Leader (1930) and Sea Devils (1931), but was impressive enough to be signed to RKO Pictures in Hollywood in 1932.⁠1  She continued singing between film assignments, performing at clubs on both coasts.

In the winter of 1932, Harriet Hilliard was fronting a floor show at the Hollywood Restaurant in Manhattan when Ozzie Nelson ducked in and was smitten with the blonde singer working the room. He introduced himself, invited her to join his band, and they were married in 1935.

For the next decade, Harriet was the photogenic centerpiece of the Ozzie Nelson Orchestra. They weathered the Depression and war years by expanding into radio, landing a regular spot on The Red Skelton Show. ⁠2 When Skelton was drafted in 1944, the Nelsons were offered their own radio program. 

With its debut on the CBS radio network in October 1944, The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet  didn’t really invent the domestic comedy. Shows like Fibber McGee and Molly (NBC, 1935–1959), Blondie (CBS, 1939–1950) and The Aldrich Family (NBC/CBS, 1939–1953) had already drawn the template for light marital banter, gentle misunderstandings, and a supporting cast of quirky neighbors and friends. 

What set Ozzie and Harriet apart was their self-contained family brand: real-life spouses playing themselves as well as their own kids, David and Ricky, who joined the cast in 1949. And, true to the business savvy he’d learned as a bandleader, Ozzie wrote, directed, and supervised every episode, setting an aspirational tone that offered catnip for advertisers targeting the emerging suburban middle class.

Unwittingly perhaps, Ozzie and Harriet conjured up a format that was uniquely suited for television. 

Determined to maintain control of his winning formula, Ozzie negotiated a deal with ABC that gave him complete ownership and creative control of the TV version – an arrangement that he could never have reached with the older, more established networks like NBC and CBS. ⁠3

Prior to launching their series on TV, the Nelsons released a theatrical feature, Here Come the Nelsons, which introduced audiences to the family they would be asked to invite into their own homes the following fall.  

The actual invitations went out at 7:30 PM on Friday, October 3, 1952, in the televised premier of The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet.

The basic framework for the show was easy to replicate from week to week: genial domestic comedy built around benign plots like a burnt dinner, a mix-up at the hardware store, or one of the boys’ teenage schemes. 

The Nelson’s family’s home in the Los Feliz district of Los Angeles was meticulously recreated on a Hollywood soundstage.

To add authenticity to their screen presence, ABC’s set designers photographed and measured the Nelsons’ real home, then meticulously recreated it on a soundstage. 

For Ozzie and his crew, the faux setting afforded total control over lighting, staging, and camera placement.⁠4  For viewers, it created the illusion that they had been welcomed straight into the Nelson home, to hang out with a stay-at-home mom who was always camera-ready, two clean-cut sons, and a dad who was always around without ever seeming engaged in any form of employment. 

At home with the perpetually camera-ready Harriett and the inexplicably unemployed Ozzie.

The televised Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet landed in a perfectly primed postwar economy. Between the GI Bill and the explosion of affordable, single-family homes in new communities like Allentown and Levittown, the Nelsons reflected an aspirational lifestyle that radiated within reach of the nearest television tower.

In this electronic petri dish, the Nelsons incubated the culture the new medium demanded: the white, increasingly affluent audience that advertisers wanted to reach, and the suburban lifestyle viewers aspired to attain.⁠5

Over the prior hundred years, America had gradually shifted – from rural, individual, and agrarian to urban, corporate, and industrial. The rapid adoption of electronic mass media accelerated that trend in the decades between the world wars. 

After the Second World War, TV shows like The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet delivered a Trojan horse to America’s doorstep at the subliminal rate of 30-frames-per-second. Hidden within each half-hour episode was the seductive corporate ideal of the American Dream.

Over the ensuing decade, Ozzie and Harriet’s saccharine portrayal of American family life was replicated across the prime time continuum.  Among their offspring: 

  • Father Knows Best (CBS/NBC, 1954–1960)
  • Leave It to Beaver (CBS/ABC, 1957–1963)
  • The Donna Reed Show (ABC, 1958–1966)
  • My Three Sons (ABC/CBS, 1960–1972)

Even The Real McCoys (ABC/CBS, 1957–1963) managed to adhere to the “family works through problems together” model, albeit in a rural rather than a suburban setting. 

Teen heartthrob Ricky Nelson, ca. 1960

Ozzie and Harriet added another valuable ingredient to the family formula when 16-year-old Ricky Nelson – already a heartthrob for female fans – launched a recording career by singing I’m Walking on the show in April, 1957. 

Ricky’s new career presented another bonanza for Ozzie, who readily saw the crossover potential between his son’s performances on television and his records.  He negotiated a contract with Imperial Records, and while the label owned the masters (in exchange for paying for the sessions), Ozzie held on to the TV rights. 

In an echo of the old “one sponsor” model, Ozzie’s deal blurred the line between programming and promotion: the TV show attracted a youthful audience. That brought the label a national platform. And the Nelson family earned both TV royalties and a share of Ricky’s recording income in a self-sustaining loop in which the TV exposure, record sales, and music publishing revenue all fed one another in a self-sustaining loop. 


16-year-old Rick Nelson makes his debut as a singer on April 10, 1957

By the early 1960s, Ricky Nelson was one of the most successful recording artists in the country – and the Nelson’s TV home was a pipeline for both family-friendly comedy and a palatable version of teen rebellion delivered with the imprimatur of parental approval. 

Ozzie and Harriet was the right show at the right time. As television wove itself ever more deeply into the fabric of the nation, the Nelsons portrayed conformity and stability in 30-minute flagons of consumer confection.  Their lives were frictionless, the house was always tidy, the family stayed together, and the outside world rarely intruded. 

And viewers could easily have all that they saw onscreen so long as they purchased the right household products.

The Nelson family ca. 1960

The last original episode of The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet aired on ABC on on April 23, 1966.  With a total of 435 episodes over fourteen seasons, the show that was created by a man with no discernible job still holds the record for the longest live-action sitcom ever aired on television. ⁠6

The world that witnessed the Nelson’s cancellation in 1966 was vastly different from the one that had enjoyed its premiere in 1952. By 1966 the country had withstood a presidential assassination, The Beatles and the British Invasion, escalating tension over the war in Southeast Asia, and the struggle for equal rights at home.  

But the end of its network run was hardly the end of the Nelsons on TV.  After dropping “The Adventures of” from the title, ABC started offering syndicated reruns of Ozzie and Harriet, packaging mostly the later seasons – after Ricky had become a pop star – to appeal to younger audiences. The show never achieved the rerun success of I Love Lucy, and by the 1990s only popped up occasionally on nostalgia cable channels like Nickelodeon’s Nick at Nite.  Suffice it to say that Ozzie and Harriet’s idealized portrayal of life in postwar America did not age well in the last decades of the 20th century or the first decades of the 21st. 

Ozzie Nelson stayed active in television production until his death in 1975 at age 69; Harriet acted occasionally and became recognized as matriarch of television before she died in 1994 at age 85. David moved into directing and producing until his death in 2011 at the age of 74.  

Rick Nelson’s music career continued into the 1970s, though it was eventually overtaken by personal and professional struggles.  Rick and most of his Stone Canyon Band perished when their DC-3 caught fire and crashed in Texas in 1985, when Rick was just 44 years old. 

Though the show never topped its slot in the ratings nor won an Emmy award, The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet remains an icon of its time. For more than a decade, the Nelsons reflected American ideals and projected American aspirations.  Their family and their show left an indelible imprint on both the medium and the country, but neither the medium nor the country were immune to change. 

__________________________

There are countless episodes and clips of The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet on YouTube. Here’s one from the first season, an episode called “The Pills.”

_______________________
1 In 1936, Harriet landed her most visible screen role opposite Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers in Follow the Fleet — a credit that still appears on every movie channel that runs the film.

2 From 1941 to 1943, the Ozzie Nelson Orchestra was the house band for The Red Skelton Show on radio, providing music between Skelton’s monologues, sketches, and recurring characters like Clem Kadiddlehopper and Deadeye. Skelton brought those characters to television in 1951, beginning on NBC and then moved to CBS in 1954, running for a total of 20 years until 1971.

3 ABC, as the “third-place” network with a thin prime-time lineup, was more willing to make deals favorable to talent in order to attract recognizable names and proven shows. That included granting Ozzie Nelson complete ownership and creative control of the TV version.

4 Ozzie & Harriet did not use the three camera before a live studio audience format that Desi Arnaz had developed for I Love Lucy.  Ozzie opted instead for the single-camera style on 35 mm film, just like a movie.  With no studio audience, a laugh track was added in postproduction.

5 The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet rarely included anything other than white characters in its 

depiction of suburban life. If  Black actors did appear, it was typically in peripheral parts – as delivery men, service workers, or musicians — and they were not integrated into the Nelsons’ social circle or storylines.  There were no recurring Black characters on the show, and no episodes where a Black guest star was central to the plot. Nevertheless, Los Angeles and Southern California – where the Nelsons lived – were actually quite racially diverse.

6 In its 14 seasons from 1952 to 1966, The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet’s 435 episodes remain the record for a live-action sitcom (though some dramas, most notably Law and Order and Grey’s Anatomy aired more than 435 episodes).  The Simpsons  has aired more than 700 episodes but is animation, not live-action . It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia began in 2005 and entered its 17th season in 2025, so it has arguably run longer than Ozzie and Harriet in years. But with shorter modern seasons producing only about 170 episodes, Ozzie and Harriet remains the undisputed champion in total episodes produced.

________________________

©2025 Paul Schatzkin

Countdown #69 Read More »

Countdown #70

January 14, 1952

NBC Today:  The Entire World As It Happens

[milestone_featured]

_______________________

September 7, 2027 will mark 100 years from the day when electronic television made its first appearance on Earth.  To generate interest in the Centennial,  this website and accompanying podcast are going to Count Down the Top 100 Milestones from the First 100 Years of Television over 100 weeks until September 7, 2027.
________________________

________________________

Born in Los Angeles in 1908,  Sylvester L. “Pat” Weaver, Jr. grew up amid the creative new industries of the 20th century: film, and radio. 

His father, Sylvester Sr., was a retired U.S. Naval officer who operated a roofing business, but his mother was Eleanor Isabel Dixon, a former silent film actress with strong ties to the world of Hollywood.  

After graduating from Dartmouth College in 1930 with a degree in English, Pat returned to Los Angeles. It didn’t take long working for his father to realize that he much preferred the creative life he had discovered in college. He returned east to New York and found work writing advertising copy for radio programs, where he quickly demonstrated a knack for combining the arts of persuasion and entertainment. 

By the 1940s, Weaver was working for Young & Rubicam, one of Madison Avenue’s most influential advertising agencies. During the period when broadcasting was still dominated by “single sponsor” programming, Weaver began advocating for what he called the “magazine” approach, wherein multiple advertisers could buy commercial segments – which gave the networks more creative control over their content. 

Pat Weaver was President of NBC Television from 1952-1955

In 1949, NBC president Niles Trammell hired Weaver to be the network’s vice president of programming. A long-tenured veteran of the network, Trammell had survived the “Paley raids” that lured  away top talent and hit shows like Amos ‘n’ Andy to CBS, but rather than stay on to rebuild, he stepped down in 1951.⁠1 Having already established his bona fides, Weaver was elevated to president of NBC, leaving him free to implement his new approach to programming and sponsorship.

Broadcasting has always been perceived by the public as a “programming” medium – a source of entertainment, news and information.  But the true mission of commercial broadcasting has always been not to deliver programs to the audience, but to deliver the audience to the advertisers.  With advertising in the driver’s seat it was often the ad salesmen who rose through the industry’s executive ranks. Weaver was not strictly an ad salesman, but his grasp on the mechanics of the business put him in a unique position to redefine the industry.  

By the time of Pat Weaver’s ascent, the major networks (at the time NBC, CBS, and DuMont) had established beachheads through much of the broadcast day.  The evenings – “prime time” – were filled with prestige dramas, variety shows, and the big-name performers who drew large national audiences.⁠2 The afternoons offered the soaps and game shows aimed squarely at homemakers. Late nights occasionally aired experimental programming.

That left the early mornings, an empty quarter randomly filled with test patterns, local news, old movies, or low-budget talk shows. The networks had yet to crack the code that could switch televisions on at sunrise and keep them glowing all day.

That unclaimed frontier is where Pat Weaver’s “magazine” model found fertile ground. 

The challenge was figuring out what kind of program would appeal to the morning audience. Weaver figured it should be credible enough to deliver the news, yet light enough to accompany breakfast; nimble enough to pivot from a political interview to a cooking demonstration; and intimate enough to feel like a friend who had dropped in for coffee.

With that formula on the drawing board, Pat Weaver decided that after January 14, 1952, every day on NBC would begin with Today. 

Passersby could look in through the windows of the RCA Exhibition Hall

To give his new morning program a touch of gravitas, Weaver built a set with the kinetic aesthetic of a bustling newsroom inside the RCA Exhibition Hall on West 49th Street in Manhattan⁠3. Floor-to-ceiling windows facing the street turned passersby into an informal outside-the-studio audience. In the background, clacking typewriters, ringing phones, and reporters roving between desks conjured the illusion that Today was plugged into the news cycle – lending just the jolt of “up and at ’em!” Weaver hoped would get people tuning in to NBC first thing in the morning.

To host the inaugural episodes of Today, Weaver turned to Dave Garroway, by then a familiar veteran of radio and television with a relaxed, conversational style who one critic called “the man with the soft sell.”

Garroway started his career as a page at NBC in New York before returning to his native Chicago in the late ’30s, where he became a popular radio announcer and disc jockey. In 1948, NBC tapped him to host Garroway at Large, a prime-time TV variety show out of Chicago that showcased his innate ability for putting guests at ease. Looking to set a tone closer to a conversation over coffee than a formal newscast, Garroway’s gift for projecting warmth through the camera made him Weaver’s first and only choice to launch Today.

Dave Garroway, host of the Today show from 1952-1961

When Today went on the air at 7:00 AM Eastern, Garroway welcomed viewers to a new kind of program    “a day-to-day picture of the entire world as it happens.” 

With that first morning broadcast, Weaver’s “magazine” model went into high gear: segments rotated between news and commentary, human-interest features, kitschy home-making tips, and fluffy entertainment.  All of the content was under NBC’s direct editorial control, and multiple advertisers bought time in blocks just like they would purchase pages in a glossy weekly like Life or Look. Companies like General Electric and American Tobacco were quick to buy in, eager to reach the new audience Today promised to deliver.

However, despite all of Pat Weaver’s meticulous planning, Today‘s dawning was less than stellar. 

In 1952, Americans mostly attuned to TV in the evenings had yet to adopt the habit of switching their set on before breakfast.  Mornings were still for coffee and radio, newspapers, or just getting out the door. Many NBC affiliates didn’t even air the program, still preferring their own local content.  Some critics lauded the new format but doubted it would change long-established household habits. Weaver had created a new “daypart” but still had to convince people to try it.   

It turned out what he needed was not a congenial, cultured host but… a monkey. 

Dave Garroway and his first “co-host,” J. Fred Muggs

About a month after Today launched, Garroway brought on his first “co-host” – a chimpanzee named J. Fred Muggs. Dressed in miniature suits, Muggs posed with celebrities who gamely took part in his antics. The gimmick worked: ratings climbed, advertisers warmed to the show, and J. Fred Muggs became a merchandising phenomenon. Garroway reportedly resented being upstaged by a simian, but Muggs bought Today the time it needed to establish a footprint in Weavers new realm. 

The mix of news, interviews, features, remotes, and the occasional spectacle became the template for all the network morning show that followed, like ABC’s Good Morning America and CBS’s Morning News. It provided the template for local variations as well.

By the late-1950s, Today had rearranged America’s morning routines, carving one more notch into television’s grip on the country and its postwar culture. 

What began as a gamble in an “empty quarter” of the broadcast day reigns on as one of the longest-running programs in television history.  Like its older sibling Meet The Press, for more than 70 years Today has anchored NBC’s mornings through wars, elections, cultural shifts, and technological change. Hosts from Hugh Downs and  Barbara Walters to Bryant Gumbel and Savannah Guthrie have come and gone, but  the format has remained remarkably resilient. 

For some 30 years, Today’s juggernaut remained unchallenged atop the morning ratings.  ABC’s Good Morning America first overtook Today in the early 1980s.  The top spot has traded hands several times since. 

Pat Weaver had set out to fill a neglected daypart, and in doing so, created an institution. But in his mind, mornings were just the beginning. There was still one more frontier to conquer: late night.  And we’ll get to that in a future installment of the Countdown to the Centennial. 

___________________

The first ten minutes of the first episode of Today:

______________________________

1 Trammel was essentially “collateral damage” in the Paley raids.  Rather than stem the exodus or spearhead the rebuilding, he partnered with the Cox and Knight newspaper families in 1952 to help establish WCKT, a new station in Miami that quickly signed on as an NBC affiliate.

2 According to Merriam‑Webster, the first known use of “prime time” in the context of television or radio—the period with the largest audience—appeared in 1947

3 In June 1994, Today moved from its original home in the RCA Exhibition Hall at 49th Street and Fifth Avenue to Studio 1A, on the ground floor of 30 Rockefeller Plaza, directly across the street from the original location.

________________________

©2025 Paul Schatzkin

Countdown #70 Read More »

Countdown #71

June 28, 1951

What’s You Talkin’ ’bout, Kingfish?

[milestone_featured]

_______________________

September 7, 2027 will mark 100 years from the day when electronic television made its first appearance on Earth.  To generate interest in the Centennial,  this website and accompanying podcast are going to Count Down the Top 100 Milestones from the First 100 Years of Television over 100 weeks until September 7, 2027.
________________________

________________________

On the radio, nobody can tell you’re not wearing blackface. 

Freeman Gosden and Charles Correll were veterans of vaudeville when they first met in the early 1920s. When they started working together, they staged tent shows that often included regional dialects in their routines.

In their act, Gosden and Correll drew on a tradition that stretched back to the early 1800s, when white performers darkened their skin with burnt cork and exaggerated their lips in a theatrical practice known as “blackface.” They found their place on stage in a uniquely American form of traveling amusement called “minstrel shows.” It was theater built on ridicule and racist caricature of an enslaved population, but it packed houses for decades before and after the Civil War.

Gosden and Correll in blackface in the 1920s

On the minstrel circuit, Gosden and Correll developed their comic rapport in skits that leaned heavily on unflattering Black stereotypes: risible dialect, laziness, scheming, and superstition. 

Gosden – who had learned wireless operation in the Navy – began experimenting with radio to promote the act. It wasn’t long before he and Correll took the act itself to the air.  

By 1925, they were performing regularly on Chicago’s independent radio station WGN, where they hosted a program called Correll and Gosden, The Life Of The Party – a 15-minute, ad-libbed comedy that featured the duo performing in various dialects, including the exaggerated ethnic jargon and speech patterns that they’d honed in blackface on the minstrel and vaudeville circuits. 

In 1926, Gosden and Correll started performing on WGN as Sam ‘n’ Henry, a serialized radio show built around those same Black caricatures. Gosden and Correll created, wrote, and performed the show – establishing a template for white actors portraying Black characters in farcically comic situations.

After a contract dispute with WGN, Gosden and Correll took their act to NBC’s Chicago affiliate, WMAQ – but for legal reasons they had to leave the character names behind. 

Old Origins, New Show

In March, 1928 they relaunched the show with a new name: Amos ‘n’ Andy. 

Gosden and  Correll in their one and only Hollywood film, Check and Double Check (1930)

By the early 1930s, Amos ’n’ Andy was the most popular radio program in America. Every Monday through Saturday, families tuned their radios to the show’s 15-minute, serialized story arcs. By the end of the decade, the show regularly reached more than 40 million listeners – Black and white – spawning merchandise, films, and phonograph recordings.

But beyond the laughter, Amos ’n’ Andy quickly became a cultural flashpoint in a country still seething in the cauldron of racial segregation – and just beginning to reckon with the cultural impact of mass media.  

Poster for Check and Double Check

Within the Black community, the response to Amos ‘n’ Andy was always complicated. Some listeners accepted the show as a rare portrayal of any kind of Black life in America; others denounced its depiction of Black people as shiftless, scheming buffoons, and for perpetuating the kind of stereotypes that were better left as relics of slavery’s past and the Jim Crow present.  Civil rights groups, most notably the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), condemned the program for promoting images of Black Americans as figures of comic ridicule rather than serious individuals worthy of full participation in American society.

Nevertheless, Amos ‘n’ Andy aired on NBC until 1938, when CBS lured it away in a lucrative sponsorship deal with Campbell Soup. 

Old Show, New Network

CBS had gone on the air only two years after RCA launched NBC, but its ambitious founder and president, William S. Paley, spent nearly two decades trying to surpass his rival in prestige and ratings. The rivalry ramped up when CBS staged what became known as the “Paley raids” – luring many of NBC’s radio stars to CBS with very favorable financial arrangements. ⁠1

Freeman Gosden and Charles Correll

Among the assets that Paley pursued were Freeman Gosden and Charles Correll and their creation, NBC’s flagship program, Amos ‘n’ Andy.  

After losing the rights to Sam ‘n’ Henry when they left WGN for WMAQ, Gosden and Correll had been careful to preserve their ownership of Amos ‘n’ Andy. But in 1948 – after airing the show on its radio network for nearly a decade – CBS made them an offer they could hardly refuse. For $2.5 million (~$34 million in 2025 dollars) CBS obtained all the rights to Gosden and Correll’s creation –  the characters, the scripts, and creative control.  Though set for life, Gosden and Correll stayed with the radio show as performers under contract to CBS and continued to write and consult on scripts and production.

New Medium, New Cast

After securing all the rights, CBS moved ahead with plans to bring Amos ’n’ Andy to television in the early 1950s. And, obviously, the first decision the network had to make was what to do about the casting. It was painfully apparent that two white actors performing Black characters in the audio equivalent of blackface was not going to translate well to television. 

L-R Alvin Childress (Amos), Spencer Williams, (Andy), and Tim Moore (Kingfish), Freeman Gosden and Charles Correll in a mock ceremony transferring the “rights” to the characters of the TV cast, ca. 1951.

With Gosden and Correll still writing and consulting from the wings, CBS called up a cast of Black actors: 

  • Tim Moore as George “Kingfish” Stevens
  • Spencer Williams as Andy Brown
  • Alvin Childress as Amos Jones
  • Ernestine Wade as Kingfish’s wife Sapphire
  • Nick Stewart as Willie “Lightnin'” Jefferson.  

Other regulars included 

  • Johnny Lee as Algonquin J. Calhoun
  • Jester Hairston as Henry Van Porter
  • Sisters Lilian and Amanda Randolph as Madame Queen and Mama Stevens

… rounding out the largest ensemble of all-Black actors ever seen on early network television.⁠2

Amos ‘n’ Andy was engulfed in controversy from the moment it premiered on CBS-TV on Thursday, June 28, 1951.

For as long as it was on the radio, Amos ’n’ Andy’s racial caricatures were “invisible.”  White audiences could imagine the characters however they pleased, and Black audiences could, at least, enjoy the storylines without the actual sight of white actors in blackface.⁠3 

By casting an all-Black ensemble for the TV show, CBS managed to circumvent the literal blackface problem, but Amos ‘n’ Andy still embodied all the racial stereotypes that grew out its origins in those  19th century minstrel shows. 

Tim Moore as “da Kingfish” in an episode of Amos-n-Andy

The NAACP and other civil rights groups immediately denounced the series for perpetuating those demeaning, one-dimensional caricatures. The Association launched a national campaign demanding the show be taken off the air, forcefully – and effectively – arguing that it portrayed outdated lampoons of African Americans as lazy, ignorant, dishonest, and clownish. The NAACP went so far as to issue a formal report, The Factual Analysis of the Amos ’n’ Andy TV Show, which itemized the demeaning portrayals and emphasized the broader harm they posed to public perception and the social standing of Black Americans.

NAACP branches across the country urged their members to contact local CBS affiliates, sponsors, and advertisers to demand the show be pulled. They organized letter-writing drives, community meetings, and editorials in Black newspapers. The campaign gained momentum when prominent voices in the Black press and civil rights community echoed the concerns, framing the show not as harmless entertainment but as a modern extension of the minstrel stereotypes.  

William S. Paley, founder of the Columbia Broadcasting System (CBS)

In the radio era it was easier for the networks – NBC until 1938, CBS from 1939 onward – to absorb most of the controversy that surrounded the show. But once it went on TV, CBS owned the property outright and was solely responsible for its content and its impact.  That meant that the steadily escalating protests were directed at a single obvious target:  William S. Paley and his network. 

The Tarnished Tiffany

Amos ’n’ Andy earned high ratings for CBS, but the backlash was too much for the network and its sponsors to ignore. The NAACP campaigns made Amos ’n’ Andy one of the first flashpoints over the continuing racial bias that persisted in the United States nearly a century after the Civil War.  And for Bill Paley, Amos ‘n’ Andy became a personal tarnish on his efforts to brand CBS as the  “Tiffany of Networks⁠4.” 

CBS never issued a formal apology, but the program was quietly canceled in 1953 after just two seasons and 65 episodes. 

Those 65 episodes were enough for the show to live on well beyond its brief life on the network. In syndication – where programs are licensed to individual stations rather than a single network and its affiliates – reruns aired well into the 1960s. The program continued to be especially popular in southern markets, where local station owners were less inclined to be persuaded by the NAACP.  

Black leaders in the urban North were more successful in pushing for the show’s cancellation, and the momentum of the civil rights movement in the 1960s made the show’s continued airing untenable. CBS – which still owned the show – quietly withdrew the series from syndication in 1966 and has kept it off the air ever since.⁠5

The legacy of Amos ’n’ Andy is as complicated as the history of the country that spawned both the medium and its content. To its benefit, Gosden, Correll, and CBS created the first television show to feature a recurring, all-Black cast.  On the other hand, the characters those actors were cast to play were shaped by decades of racist tropes and degrading parody.

Amos ‘n’ Andy last flickered through the ether in 1966, but clips and whole episodes can be found today on YouTube.⁠6 

Nevertheless, Amos ‘n’ Andy vanishing from the airwaves cleared the path for more authentic representations of Black life in America.  On September 17, 1968 – just two years after the last episode of Amos ‘n’ Andy aired in any kind of broadcast syndication – NBC presented Diahann Carroll as a widowed nurse raising her son in Julia, the first American TV series to star a Black woman in a non-servant role. ⁠7In the decade that followed, The Jeffersons, Good Times, and The Cosby Show would offer a broader – if still contested – spectrum of Black life on television.

The Medium is Becoming The Message

From the first century of television, Amos ’n’ Andy remains the archetype of a cautionary tale. It asks us to look closely at who gets to tell stories, how those stories are framed, and what we choose to laugh at.   And it is fitting to remember that while Amos ‘n’ Andy‘s white creators went on to wealth and acclaim, the actors who portrayed their characters on television went on to lives of modest obscurity. 

In some respects, the evolution of Amos ‘n’ Andy embodies both the medium and its audience. In its earliest days, television reflected the status quo. With the imperative to reach larger audiences with higher production costs, the medium began to reflect the changes that enveloped the postwar nation.  And as television emerged from its late 1940s infancy into its troubled adolescence in the 1960s, it became a driving force in the changes to come.  

_______________________

Speaking of YouTube: In this 1986 documentary, George Kirby “takes a fond look at the controversial radio and television show and attempts to determine if the series was a positive first step for Blacks into the world of entertainment or not, and examines the events that led to the show’s expulsion from the airwaves in 1966 after complaints from civil rights activists. Highlighted with rare clips of radio show creators Freeman Gosden and Charles Correll, and clips from the Amos n’ Andy TV series. Commentary by Alvin Childress, Ernestine Wade, Reverend Jesse Jackson, Redd Foxx, Marla Gibbs, and Henry Lee Moon.

________________________

1 Among the stars Paley poached from NBC were Jack Benny, Burns & Allen, and Edgar Bergen.

2 Research affirms that The Amos ’n’ Andy Show was the first television series to feature an all-Black cast—and remained unique in that regard for the next two decades. A 1949 CBS show, Uptown Jubilee (also known as Harlem Jubilee or Sugar Hill Times), was an all-Black variety program, but it wasn’t a serialized sitcom and aired only briefly, for five episodes.

3 While Gosden and Correll continued to play the principal characters for as long as Amos ‘n’ Andy aired on the radio, by the late 1940s, Black actors took their place for in-person promotional appearances – but the voices were still two white men.

4 It’s not clear when CBS started calling itself “The Tiffany of Networks.” It started shortly after World War II when Bill Paley started to cultivate an air of prestige and quality for his networks news and entertainment programming. The branding may have gained some traction in the mid 1950s when CBS conducted color-TV demonstrations in a building formerly occupied by a branch of  Tiffany & Co., the upper-crust jewelry and fashion brand.

5 Like its competitors NBC (now part of Comcast Universal) and ABC (now part of Disney), CBS has gone through numerous corporate reconfigurations. As of 2025, the newly merged Paramount Skydance Corporation owns CBS – and the continuing rights to the vanquished Amos ‘n’ Andy.

6 That Amos ‘n’ Andy has found new life on the Internet is a reflection of the challenges of the 21st century media environment.  CBS still owns the rights, so the presence of episodes on YouTube is unauthorized. They have been uploaded by private collectors from old syndication prints, kinescopes, and videotapes that circulated before 1966.  Though CBS has not re-released or licensed the series, its enforcement is inconsistent; uploads often get taken down when flagged, but many slip through because of the sheer volume of material and the spotty nature of copyright policing online.

7 At time of this writing, the premier of Julia on NBC in 1968 is slated to appear as #46 in the Countdown to the Centennial.

________________________

©2025 Paul Schatzkin

Countdown #71 Read More »